Breaking: Inside ThredUp's Play to Own Both Sides of Resale with Peer-to-Peer Launching
I spoke with Kristen Brophy, ThredUp’s Senior Vice President of Marketing about the 0% seller fee, how they're handling returns, and whether one platform can actually do both.
I’m Emily Stochl and this is Pre-Loved 🎤 the must-read newsletter about the business and culture of vintage and secondhand fashion. If you work in resale, your $5 subscription is likely a business expense.
Hey hi hello! While secondhand shopping is rapidly growing in popularity, reselling is another hurdle entirely. Every sale is a calculation: is the payout worth the effort? This tension is part of what pushed ThredUp to launch peer-to-peer Direct Listings this week. I spoke with Kristen Brophy, ThredUp’s Senior Vice President of Marketing about the 0% seller fee, how they're handling returns, and whether one platform can actually do both managed marketplace and peer-to-peer. More below.
💌 Today’s newsletter includes: ThredUp pulling in peer-to-peer listings with a $0 seller fee, a Goodwill “superstore” is taking over a former CVS in the East Bay, Chanel wins another upcycling lawsuit in Paris, GQ asks if vintage shopping has a “vibe” problem, and Alexa Demie's i-D zine is selling for $200 on eBay.
→ Follow me on Instagram
→ Follow me on TikTok
ThredUp is Adding Peer-to-Peer Sales to Their Managed Marketplace:
For two decades, the resale industry has operated in a bifurcated split: you either handed your clothes off to a managed service like ThredUp and waited for your cut of the sale, or you listed the items yourself on a peer-to-peer platform like Poshmark, Etsy, eBay, or Depop and spent your own time negotiating the sale — a trade-off in order to receive a larger payout.
On June 9, ThredUp collapsed those silos.
The San Francisco-based resale platform, founded in 2009, is launching Direct Listings, a peer-to-peer option that lets sellers list secondhand clothing items themselves — directly, on the same platform with ThredUp’s own managed marketplace inventory. “Consumers shouldn't have to choose between convenience and control," said Kristen Brophy, ThredUp’s Senior Vice President of Marketing. “Bringing both under one digital roof is just the natural next step for circular fashion.”
For several months, ThredUp’s Direct Selling program has been in a beta test with select users, and the early results made a case for why now is the right moment to bridge managed marketplaces with peer-to-peer. The company found that sellers were routing their best items — the designer pieces, “true vintage,” things with real resale gravity — away from managed marketplaces and toward peer-to-peer platforms where they could capture a maximum commission. This dichotomy presents not just a missed revenue opportunity — but in a resale reality where procuring high-quality supply is the industry’s biggest challenge, it meant ThredUp’s managed inventory was being skimmed of its premium tier before it ever arrived. “Sometimes sellers want to clean out their closet, mail us a bag, and let us do the heavy lifting,” Brophy said. “Other times, they have a single high-value item they want to list immediately for a higher payout.” Direct Listings are built for those instances — and ThredUp put a $20 minimum on the feature, thus routing high-volume, lower-value items back toward the original Clean Out bag option.
In beta, the average selling price for a Direct Listing landed at $60 — more than double what ThredUp's managed marketplace averages, with 18% of beta listings priced above $100, receiving a 12% sell-through rate on premium items. “The peer-to-peer model naturally empowers people with high-quality, premium items to list directly and keep the profit,” said Brophy. “We hear from customers that they’re happy to take a few extra minutes to list something themselves because the extra earnings make the effort worth it.”
To attract sellers to the new listing option, ThredUp proposes a 0% seller fee, which is the sharpest and most competitive part of this announcement. The move is a shot at other peer-to-peer incumbents: Poshmark charges 20% on sales above $15, Depop charges a payment processing fee of 3.3% plus $0.45 per transaction, eBay charges 15% the total sale amount on clothing, plus a $0.30-$0.40 transaction fee. 0% seller fees can be viewed as a bid to compete with the European peer-to-peer resale titan, Vinted, which entered the U.S. market earlier this year with its own 0% seller fee.
To offset the lack of seller fees, ThredUp is leaning on its existing physical infrastructure — its distribution centers and robust customer service operation — to absorb costs that have kneecapped peer-to-peer platforms since the beginning. This includes managing the significant challenge of returns cost. On other peer-to-peer platforms, a return dispute lands between two strangers negotiating the details. ThredUp is absorbing that process entirely — buyers can purchase return protection at checkout, or sellers can opt to cover it out of their payout. Either way, if a return happens, the item ships to one of ThredUp's centralized distribution centers and the company handles the refund, rerouting the item into their managed marketplace if appropriate. "The seller gets to keep their payout regardless," Brophy said, "and they don't have to deal with the hassle of managing the return." That infrastructure — built over fifteen years of processing resale — is not something a new entrant replicates quickly.
Listing quality has historically been another peer-to-peer weak point, and ThredUp is addressing it through AI built directly into the listing flow. When a seller photographs an item, the platform removes backgrounds, optimizes the image, and generates suggested product descriptions — producing something that looks as close as possible to a ThredUp managed listing. How well that holds up as the beta scales is the real test. But Brophy said, "Instead of hiring an army of people to manually approve listings, we are putting the millions of dollars we've invested in proprietary technology directly into the seller's hands."
Early responses from sellers in the beta seem positive, though for buyers, so much hinges on price. Pricing is unique in this combined marketplace. Sellers set their own prices with Direct Listing — though ThredUp feeds its own resale data and price recommendations into the listing process, suggesting competitive ranges based on what comparable items have actually sold for. The company expects some pricing variance with individuals listing items, but the data layer is designed to keep Direct Listing prices from drifting so far from managed inventory that it confuses the shopper browsing both.
The apparel resale market is projected to exceed $80 billion by 2030. ThredUp’s thesis is that the two halves of that market don’t have to compete for the same consumer dollar — or the same seller. “By offering both managed clean-out services and peer-to-peer options under one roof,” Brophy said, “we eliminate the need for consumers to jump between multiple apps to buy and sell.” A seller who drops a bag of Gap basics into a Clean Out kit can, in the same session, list a vintage Gucci piece and keep the larger commission. The Direct Seller beta is open now, and whether the combination of fee advantage and logistics muscle is enough to peel sellers away from platforms they already know is an open question. But the resale market has spent twenty years waiting for someone to solve the marketplace tradeoff rather than just pick a side. ThredUp is making its case it’s the one to do it. "Over the next few years, we expect this move to cement ThredUp as the definitive starting point for buying and selling secondhand," Brophy said.
As always, let Pre-Loved know what you think!
